Case Study - Sydney's Inner city from the slum to highly valued precincts

Before you read the extract below, we all know that a large part of Sydney old quarters (known as Inner-city) are still intact, mostly survive from demolition during 1970s. Now these old houses have become the highest value properties in the country. Not only they are highly desired house to live in it also bring ripple effect to the immediate streetscape and urban areas to become vibrant cultural precincts.

Extract from book "Planning Sydney's Future". It outlined how in the past old houses were perceived as problem to the society. Now condition changed so people shouldn't see it as problem but our cultural heritage we should preserve. This also proved that we can't solve social problems with bulldozers which is happening in cities like Shanghai, Beijing...

"At the end of the Second World War Australia faced the worst housing crisis in its history. A survey conducted by the Commonwealth government in 1944 showed a national housing shortage of almost 200 000 dwellings, with Sydney needing about 35 000 of these. This was before replacing the 19 000 inner-city 'slum' dwelling that were earmarked for demolition. The 1947 census showed that of Sydney's population of almost one and a half million, about three-quarters lived in private houses occupied by only one family, another 15 per cent lived in flats. while the remaining ten per cent shared private houses or lived in boarding houses. On average, four people lived in single-family private houses, while six lived in share houses. But in the poorer parts of the inner city it was not uncommon for three or four families to be sharing overcrowded and often unsanitary terrace houses.

With demobilisation came demands for postwar reconstruction. Blueprints for better houses and better cities were an important part of armed services propaganda. In 1945 the Sydney architect Walter Bunning wrote an influential book about the past, present and future of Australian housing which he called 'Homes in the Sun'. In his foreword H. C. Coombs, director~general of postwar reconstruction, wrote that the book 'will be of direct and personal interest to every Australian man and woman who will in the coming years be setting up their own homes'. Bunning wanted new homes to be built 'to admit sunshine and fresh air, to have healthy surroundings, peace and quiet and to suit our climate and traditions'.

Like the Cumberland planners. Bunning painted a bleak picture of Sydney's slums. which he characterised as having narrow, ugly streets and pocket-handkerchief allotments, forcing children to play in 'lanes and alleys' and their parents 'to sit on their doorsteps' (1). Such attitudes encouraged property interests to welcome the expansion of the City core into suburbs like Pyrmont, Chippendale and Woolloomooloo because substandard housing would be replaced by commerce and industry. In other inner suburbs, like Paddington, Redfern, Surry Hills, Alexandria, Waterloo, Erskineville, Newtown, Glebe and Balmain it was assumed that demolition and rebuilding would be required for most of the houses and that the New South Wales Housing Commission. created in 1941, would do the bulk of the work."

'Planning Sydney's Future' by Peter Spearritt & Christina Demarco. Published 1988 by Allen & Unwin Sydney

Article "Be it ever so humble", published May 11, 2002 at
Sydney Morning Herald explains the transformation Sydney's Inner city had experience.
Quote : "Sydney's smart - and expensive - Victorian houses were once hosts to squalor and plague", writes Anne Davies.

(1) Scene like this is common in the large part of Europe nowadays. It is in fact the healthiest, and more environmental friendly way of living. The low, tight and intimate neighbourhoods also create strong sense of community.

Slow Living & old market

On a grey and bitterly cold early Saturday morning at Dunedin's weekly farmers' market we struggle with our bags of shopping as we make our way awkwardly through the crowded pathway. As we do we cannot but think of the new, shiny supermarket that has opened this week down the road from where we live. Its well- lit, warm interior beckons and it prompts us to wonder why we are here rather than there. As we do, we pause for a moment and take in the scene around us: the bustling stalls selling local fruit and vegetables, people tasting the organic pork sausages, the smell of coffee in the air, as well as much talk and laughter. We know we are putting up with the cold because we are committed to local food systems but we are also here because we enjoy the the sensory nature and the sociality of this space. There is a quality to this kind of space that distinguishes it from many other everyday experiences of space, including the new supermarket. Such an observation firstly reminds us that places are not just particular physical sites but they are also constituted as settings of interaction. Secondly, the material specificity of the farmers' market is appealing because it is different from, and challenges, conventional experiences of space in the global everyday: culture, traditionally thought of as bound to locality, is now derived from more abstract, deterritorialized contexts and relations. What implications does such a deterritorialized existence have for any conceptualization of the spaces of slow living? We will argue in this section that the concept of 'place' retains a significance in the global everyday and that deterritorialization paradoxically can contribute to a revitalization of the site of 'the local'. Modernity has initiated fundamental changes in the relationship between space and place.

Quote taken from "Deterritorialization, the Local and Place ", Slow Living.

Full Reference:
Parkins, Wendy & Craig, Geoffrey. [2006], Slow Living, UNSW Press

An argument of our Contemporary City = Generic City

These are some of the important quotes argue against the current trend cities are transforming into modern monoculture:

"[Tragedy] I don't believe anyone will ever be able to make any city council understand that from an urbanistic point of view, the most attractive parts of the city are precisely those areas where nobody has ever done anything. I believe a city, by definition, wants to have something done in those areas. That is the tragedy." quote by Architect Rem Koolhaas & Designer Bruce Mau, published at S,M,L,XL

"The loss of Singapore's historic center foreshadows a disturbing global phenomenon. It is sad enough when a people and a city expunge their own cultural achievements, but in the twentieth century, throughout the world, where historic architecture in old cities is lost, it is frequently replaced with the new architecture of an international modern monoculture. Whether in northern or southern climates, in Asia, African, European, or American cultures, the generic buildings of modern development change little in response to their geographic and social surroundings. Just as American fast-food chains offer identical dishes, with the same names, in the same wrappers, by waiters in matching uniforms, so most of the new architecture of Singapore primarily reflects the economic formulas of modern speculative development." quote by Anthony Tung, published at Preserving the World's Great Cities. The destruction and renewal of the historic metropolis

From Louisana Manifesto, architect Jean Nouvel stated : "In 2005, more than ever, architecture is annihilating places, banalizing them, violating them. Sometimes it replaces the landscape, creates it in its own image, which is nothing but another way of effacting it. "........ "The global economy is accentuating the effects of the dominant architecture, the type that claims “we don’t need context”. And yet debate on this galloping frenzy does not exist: architectural criticism, invoking the limits of the discipline, is content with aesthetic and stylistic reflections devoid of any analysis of the real, and ignores the crucial historical clash that – more insistently every day – sets a global architecture against an architecture of situations, generic architecture against an architecture of specificity. Is our modernity today simply the direct descendant of the modernity of the 20th century, devoid of any spirit of criticism? Does it consist simply of parachuting solitary objects on to the face of the planet? Shouldn’t it rather be looking for reasons, correspondences, harmonies, differences in order to propose an ad-hoc architecture, here and now? " ......."In the name of the pleasure of living on this Earth, we must resist the urbanism of zones, networks and grids, the automatic rot that is obliterating the identity of the cities of all continents, in all climates, feeding on cloned offices, cloned dwellings, cloned shops, thirsting for the already thought, the already seen in order to avoid thinking and seeing."

"Distinctiveness is key, for although cities draw from each others' experiences the danger is that pioneering cities around the world quickly become textbook case studies for city officials. Cities then tend to adopt generic models of success without taking into account the local characteristic and conditions that contributed to those successes. The result is a homogeneous pastiche of buildings - aquariums, convention centres, museums, shops and restaurants - that prove to be remarkably similar the world over." Quoted from The Creative City: A Toolkit for Urban Innovators

State Assembly Building at the river front #1

The DUN - Dewan Undangan Negeri (State Legislative Assembly building). The bulk size of this building will dominant the skyline of Kuching city. It is built on the site where originally covered with thick vegetation prominently forms the unique image of Kuching. Now with the clearing had been done to the water edge, you can see the beginning of urbanising the other side of the river.

Diminishing way of life #1 - Beijing

It is not hard to find a beautiful scene like this in Italy where locals still live in traditional way (even in the cities) and this way of life will go on pretty much forever.

In China, its own unique cultural heritage and the way of life will be diminished in the name of modernisation.

Click photo to view original photo and narration at Flickr.

River city and 'working river' study - Palembang

Palembang, second largest city in the Indonesia island of Sumatra is a thriving city. The city is not as modern as Kuching city, still maintains large section of old areas along its river. The Musi is still a working river brings much activities for the city centre in the form of boat transport between both banks is not only crucial for the city's economy and also the identity and livelihood of its people depends on it. River side residents travel to opposite bank the city centre to shops for daily needs; agriculture goods are delivered here via boats; fishing boats docks here and load the daily catch to the markets.

Imagine like other cities in the world Palembang rushes to develop its old waterfront strips into a place of recreation and tourism the 'working river ' activities (as shown on the photos) will be diminished. Boat activities will be moved or centralised in new loading points thus this part of the river will lose its vibrancy. The only boat travel between both banks will be only the sightseeing tourist boat. Businesses on the proximity of river banks depend so much on sales and delivery of goods from boats will be greatly affected.

One of the prominent example is Sydney's diminishing status as 'working harbour'. Debate can be viewed here.

Photos by Desmond Ong











River city study - Luang Prabang, Laos



Luang Prabang - "A royal gem, reclining against the mountains and dangling its feet in the river" "Luang Prabang, made a Unesco World Heritage city for both its beautiful buildings and the serenity of its natural surrounds, has become Lao PDR's foremost tourist showpiece" Lonely Planet.

Luang Prabang, a Laos city with current population of 103,000

No other river city in the world has this unique character like Luang Prabang. Nature is the dominant feature. It covers much of the city center and the whole stretch of the riverbank. This portrays image of Laos to the outside world that this country still live in the old world. Timeless and untouched by the modernity.

Urban centre is well integrated with the landscape

Has impressive historic buildings without being imposing but blend well with the existing landscape

Like Kuching, Luang Prabang has good blend of well preserved colonial buildings and local architecture, set against rivers and mountains of beautiful natural beauty, which led to Luang Prabang designation as a World Heritage site in 1995. As the result of such an early recognition before the country's opening to outside world has effectively protected the old city and its beautiful surrounds from the ravages of hasty development.



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luang_Prabang

Kuching riverfront view from the hotel [2]



Original photo is posted at Flickr. This is one of the most important shot found. It shows the typical view from hotel room facing the Sarawak river (north to north western view) (map and views diagram coming soon). Taken on a sunny day the context are clearly visible. The owner of this photo and also the previous shot had made a comment about her preference of the trees area on the opposite bank (right) remains untouched. In favour to this, the shot has been panned to the left to exclude the new nearly completed - the Assembly Building which can be seen from the previous photo (go to post). This photo represents Kuching's originally character.




Kuching riverfront view from the hotel [1]















Original photo is posted at Flickr. This is one of the most important shot found. It shows the typical view from hotel room facing the Sarawak river (north to north western view) (map and views diagram coming soon). Taken on a sunny day the context are clearly visible. The owner of this photo and also the proceeding shot had made a comment about her preference of the trees area on the opposite bank remains untouched. The current condition shows the new nearly completed building - the Assembly Building is actually changing the quality of the existing aspect forever.

At KL's wet market



1. _M220119bw copy.jpg, 2. Wet wet wet market, 3. He's too shy to look at me, 4. _M108552bw copy.jpg, 5. Petai, 6. In the wet Market (Kuala Lumpur)

Bazaar Baru Market (Kuala Lumpur)
This lively market sells clothes, toys, buckets, stationery, noodles, spices, fresh meat and live, flapping catfish, as well as a staggering array of weird and wonderful tropical fruit. Overweight cats loiter around the wet market looking for scraps, and locals struggle through the narrow aisles with huge bags of shopping. Just wondering round is a heady, sensory experience, particularly for the sense of smell. (Lonely Planet)

Pudu Market (Kuala Lumpur)
Pudu Market is KL's biggest wet and dry market. It's a frenetic place, full of squawking chickens, frantic shoppers and porters forcing their way through the crowds with outrageous loads.....Arrive early in the morning to experience the market at its most lively and pungent. You can recover the sensory overload at the attached hawker court. (Lonely Planet)

The market that defines the city [Melbourne]


Queen Victoria Market

1. red yellow and green, 2. queen victoria market, 3. Lady's Fingers, 4. queen victoria market, 5. Specialising in Dips, 6. queen victoria market


Queen Victoria Market (Melbourne)
Opened in the 1870s, Queen Victoria Market remains one of the best loved of Melbourne's institutions. Its collection of huge, decorative open-sided sheds and high-roofed halls is fronted along Victoria Street by restored shops, their original awnings held up with decorative iron posts. Although undeniably quaint and tourist-friendly, the market is a boisterous, down-to-earth affair where you can buy practically anything from new and secondhand clothes to fresh fish at bargain prices. Stallholders and shoppers seem just as diverse as the goods on offer: Vietnamese, Italian and Greek greengrocers pile their colourful produce high and vie for your attention, while the huge variety of deliciously smelly cheeses effortlessly draws customers to the old-fashioned deli hall. (Rough Guides)

At the Italian Markets



1. Fruit Vendor, 2. Bologna Street Markets, 3. Spending last penny, 4. Madama di Palazzo, 5. sguardi incrociati, 6. ripe hardiness06


"To Italians, a city without a fresh food market at its heart us a dead city. Their markets are thriving subcultures that provide an insight into the psyche of the city." Terry Durack, Travel + Leisure Magazine

"In an era of supermarket aisles, refrigerated cabinets and processed everything, this is a rare opportunity for the city to meet the country face-to-face." Travel + Leisure Magazine

"You can tell a lot about an Italian city by its market. No two are the same." Carla Coulson

Get soul into the city, landscape chief urges

Perth needs to move away from the American streetscape design, heavily influenced by car use, and adopt a European pedestrian-friendly approach with a focus on creating welcoming and vibrant village centres. Continue article

http://www.aila.org.au/NEWS/InNEWS/GrabashDec07.htm

References


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


BOOKS





  • Cities
Burdett, Richard (editor), [2006], Cities, Architecture and Society: 10th International Architecture Exhibition - Venice Biennale 2006, Volume 1 & 2, Marsilio Editori

Burdett, Richard (editor), [2006], City-Port: 10th International Architecture Exhibition - Venice Biennale 2006, Volume 1 & 2, Marsilio Editori

Barrett, Jennifer (editor) & Butler-Bowden, Caroline, [2001], Debating the City - An anthology, Historic House Trust of New South Wales & University of Western Sydney

Burdett, R & Sudjic, D, [2007], The Endless City, Phaidon

Kerr, Alex. [1996], Lost Japan, Lonely Planet Publication

Kerr, Alex. [2001],al porta Dogs and Demons-Tales from the Dark Side of Modern Japan, Hill and Wang

Koolhaas Rem & Mau, Bruce, [1998], S,M,L,XL, Second Edition, Monacelli Press

Yamasaki, Matsahumi, [1994], Ktoyo: Its Cityscape, Traditions and Heritage, Process Architecture, no116




  • Urban Studies
Landry, Charles, [2008 2nd edition], The Creative City - The Toolkit for Urban Innovators, Earthscan Publishing

Tung, Anthony M, [2001], Preserving the world's great cities. The destruction and renewal of the historic metropolis, Clarkson Potter/Publisher.

Peter Spearritt & Christina Demarco, [1988], Planning Sydney's Future, Allen & Unwin Sydney

David J. Smiley, [2002], Sprawl and public space : redressing the mall, National Endowment for the Arts ; New York, Distributed by Princeton Architectural Press




  • Traditional markets and streetscape

Illustrations by A. Kasim Abas ; text by Peter Kedit [2005], Sarawak sketchbook, EDM Books

Cliff, Stafford & Chabaneix, Gilles de. [2003], The Way We Live : Making Homes/Creating Lifestyles, Thames & Hudson




  • Living

Farrelly, Elizabeth M. [2007], Bubbleland: The Dangers of Happiness, UNSW Press

Parkins, Wendy & Craig, Geoffrey. [2006], Slow Living, UNSW Press




  • Travel

Rough Guides, [2003], The Rough Guide to Malaysia, Singapore & Brunei, the Penguin Group


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

JOURNALS

Kerb : Journal of Landscape Architecture 'Future Cities' Issue 16 2007/2008



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

PAPERS

Nouvel, Jean [2008] Louisiana Manifesto


----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------


CONFERENCES AND EXHIBITIONS


"Cities, Architecture and Society", Venice Biennale 2006 - 10th International Architecture Exhibition

"City-Port", Venice Biennale 2006 - 10th International Architecture Exhibition

"Time", AILA / IFLA Conference Sydney 2006

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

WEBSITES

http://www.aila.org.au/ (Australia Institute of Landscape Architects)

http://www.worldchanging.com/ (World Changing - Change Your Thinking)

http://www.pps.org/ (Project for Public Spaces (PPS): Building Community, Creating Places,Using Common Sense)

http://www.urban-age.net/endless_city/_ELC.html (Urban Age Network)


 

blogger templates |